Newhorizonsre.com Search Results

Built in 1899 but extensively rebuilt for modern living, this one-of-a-kind Fort Collins property combines historic character, thoughtful design, and exceptional versatility with two homes on a 7,700 sq ft lot and no HOA or Metro District. The 1,966 sq ft main home offers 4 bedrooms (1 non-conforming--no closet) and 4 bathrooms, with major improvements completed in 2026 including a new foundation, walls, floors, roof, electrical, and plumbing-all permitted. Inside, engineered hardwood floors, custom built-ins, hand-troweled walls, integrated LED lighting, and a fireplace separating the living and dining spaces create a warm, modern feel. The kitchen features quartz countertops with waterfall edge, walnut cabinetry, induction range, stainless appliances, bar fridge, and a well-designed butler's pantry. The primary suite includes a double vanity and custom lighting, while additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, an office, or everyday living. Outside, enjoy a new driveway and steps, fenced yard, stone patio crafted from reclaimed historic Fort Collins sidewalk stones, EV-ready 220V outlet, and updated landscaping and irrigation. The separate 1,212 sq ft ADU adds tremendous opportunity with 3 bedrooms/flex spaces, a full kitchen, bath, private yard, hot tub, and alley parking. Currently operated as a permitted short-term rental, the property has historically averaged approximately 80% occupancy and about $70,000/year in gross rental income, according to the seller. The ADU is offered furnished, creating a compelling option for income generation, guests, or multi-generational living. This is a rare combination of location, craftsmanship, flexibility, and income potential in the heart of Fort Collins. ***PLEASE NOTE: Square footage, bedroom, bathroom, and off-street parking (listed under garage) totals are all combined totals of both the main home and the ADU/STR home.***

7 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1069317 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

Built in 1899 but extensively rebuilt for modern living, this one-of-a-kind Fort Collins property combines historic character, thoughtful design, and exceptional versatility with two homes on a 7,700 sq ft lot and no HOA or Metro District. The 1,966 sq ft main home offers 4 bedrooms (1 non-conforming--no closet) and 4 bathrooms, with major improvements completed in 2026 including a new foundation, walls, floors, roof, electrical, and plumbing-all permitted. Inside, engineered hardwood floors, custom built-ins, hand-troweled walls, integrated LED lighting, and a fireplace separating the living and dining spaces create a warm, modern feel. The kitchen features quartz countertops with waterfall edge, walnut cabinetry, induction range, stainless appliances, bar fridge, and a well-designed butler's pantry. The primary suite includes a double vanity and custom lighting, while additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, an office, or everyday living. Outside, enjoy a new driveway and steps, fenced yard, stone patio crafted from reclaimed historic Fort Collins sidewalk stones, EV-ready 220V outlet, and updated landscaping and irrigation. The separate 1,212 sq ft ADU adds tremendous opportunity with 3 bedrooms/flex spaces, a full kitchen, bath, private yard, hot tub, and alley parking. Currently operated as a permitted short-term rental, the property has historically averaged approximately 80% occupancy and about $70,000/year in gross rental income, according to the seller. The ADU is offered furnished, creating a compelling option for income generation, guests, or multi-generational living. This is a rare combination of location, craftsmanship, flexibility, and income potential in the heart of Fort Collins. ***PLEASE NOTE: Square footage, bedroom, bathroom, and off-street parking (listed under garage) totals are all combined totals of both the main home and the ADU/STR home.***

320 Edwards St, Fort Collins

$1,272,000

Rare opportunity to own a well-maintained fourplex on a huge corner lot in the heart of Old Town Fort Collins-just a few blocks from vibrant restaurants, shops, and entertainment. With a strong history of zero vacancy, this property offers excellent potential for both investors and owner-occupants looking to offset their mortgage with rental income. The property features a versatile unit mix, with each unit offering unique character with original built-ins and historic charm, complemented by thoughtful updates throughout. Tenants enjoy shared laundry in the basement, large porches, and a secure, gated area for bicycle storage. The two-car garage with attic space provides excellent storage and or additional rental income. Ample street parking on Mathews. The large lot may hold addition value for a buyer. All units are currently leased, offering immediate income and a turnkey opportunity in one of Fort Collins' most desirable neighborhoods.

1055289 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

Rare opportunity to own a well-maintained fourplex on a huge corner lot in the heart of Old Town Fort Collins-just a few blocks from vibrant restaurants, shops, and entertainment. With a strong history of zero vacancy, this property offers excellent potential for both investors and owner-occupants looking to offset their mortgage with rental income. The property features a versatile unit mix, with each unit offering unique character with original built-ins and historic charm, complemented by thoughtful updates throughout. Tenants enjoy shared laundry in the basement, large porches, and a secure, gated area for bicycle storage. The two-car garage with attic space provides excellent storage and or additional rental income. Ample street parking on Mathews. The large lot may hold addition value for a buyer. All units are currently leased, offering immediate income and a turnkey opportunity in one of Fort Collins' most desirable neighborhoods.

223 E Elizabeth St, Fort Collins

$789,000

Charming Old Town Fort Collins bungalow filled with character, thoughtful updates, and wonderfully flexible spaces! This three-bedroom ranch showcases beautifully refinished original hardwood floors, fresh interior and exterior paint, and a bright, updated kitchen with new butcher-block countertops. New recessed lighting and trim add a clean, polished finish throughout. Outside, cedar accents and professional landscaping create exceptional curb appeal, while established garden beds offer peppers, tomatoes and more ready to enjoy. The private backyard features a tucked-away hot tub, a chicken-coop-ready area, and convenient alley access. The former oversized two-car garage was transformed into an impressive year-round art studio complete with heating, cooling, and a bathroom-perfect for creative pursuits, hobbies, a workshop, or a private home office. Prefer to have the garage space? - No problem! We'll turn it back into a garage for you! Located just minutes from Old Town's shops, restaurants, and local attractions, this inviting neighborhood is known for its mature tree-lined streets and one-of-a-kind homes. A special property offering vintage charm, modern updates, and the quintessential Old Town lifestyle!

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1069402 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

Charming Old Town Fort Collins bungalow filled with character, thoughtful updates, and wonderfully flexible spaces! This three-bedroom ranch showcases beautifully refinished original hardwood floors, fresh interior and exterior paint, and a bright, updated kitchen with new butcher-block countertops. New recessed lighting and trim add a clean, polished finish throughout. Outside, cedar accents and professional landscaping create exceptional curb appeal, while established garden beds offer peppers, tomatoes and more ready to enjoy. The private backyard features a tucked-away hot tub, a chicken-coop-ready area, and convenient alley access. The former oversized two-car garage was transformed into an impressive year-round art studio complete with heating, cooling, and a bathroom-perfect for creative pursuits, hobbies, a workshop, or a private home office. Prefer to have the garage space? - No problem! We'll turn it back into a garage for you! Located just minutes from Old Town's shops, restaurants, and local attractions, this inviting neighborhood is known for its mature tree-lined streets and one-of-a-kind homes. A special property offering vintage charm, modern updates, and the quintessential Old Town lifestyle!

329 E Elizabeth St, Fort Collins

$703,700

This beautifully remodeled home is in a great location! Walk or bike to Old Town or CSU campus, just 2.5 blocks from Nick's Restaurant on College Ave. Large lot, detached garage. Short Term Rentals allowed by zoning, please see City of Fort Collins for licensure info. All of the home furnishings and furniture at the property are available for purchase.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061974 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

This beautifully remodeled home is in a great location! Walk or bike to Old Town or CSU campus, just 2.5 blocks from Nick's Restaurant on College Ave. Large lot, detached garage. Short Term Rentals allowed by zoning, please see City of Fort Collins for licensure info. All of the home furnishings and furniture at the property are available for purchase.

308 Garfield St, Fort Collins

$629,000

Your ideal investment opportunity has arrived! This legal duplex, just minutes from Old Town Fort Collins and the CSU campus, offers the flexibility investors love-live in one unit and rent the other, or lease both for maximum income potential. Thoughtfully updated and well maintained, this property is truly turnkey. Recent improvements include fresh exterior paint (June 2026) and a comprehensive 2022 renovation. 2022 Upstairs updates: refinished original hardwood floors, refinished kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, new dishwasher, updated light fixtures, fresh interior paint, and new window coverings. 2022 Downstairs updates: new LVP flooring, new shower tile, refinished kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, updated light fixtures, fresh interior paint, and new window coverings. 2022 Shared spaces updates: freshly painted laundry room and stairwell, plus refinished hardwood stairs. Additional capital improvements include a radon mitigation system installed in 2023 and the 2011 separation of mechanical systems along with egress window installation, establishing the property's legal duplex status with the City of Fort Collins. Outside, you'll find off-alley parking for up to four vehicles, a charming backyard complete with a white picket fence, and a full two-car garage. The property also earned an impressive 8/10 score on the City of Fort Collins 2024 Energy Audit. Consistently rented with high-quality tenants, this duplex has a proven rental history. Even better, the upstairs lease expires July 31, 2026, creating an ideal opportunity for an owner-occupant looking to offset their mortgage while building long-term wealth. Whether you're a savvy investor or a future house hacker, this Fort Collins gem checks all the boxes.

1062133 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

Your ideal investment opportunity has arrived! This legal duplex, just minutes from Old Town Fort Collins and the CSU campus, offers the flexibility investors love-live in one unit and rent the other, or lease both for maximum income potential. Thoughtfully updated and well maintained, this property is truly turnkey. Recent improvements include fresh exterior paint (June 2026) and a comprehensive 2022 renovation. 2022 Upstairs updates: refinished original hardwood floors, refinished kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, new dishwasher, updated light fixtures, fresh interior paint, and new window coverings. 2022 Downstairs updates: new LVP flooring, new shower tile, refinished kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, updated light fixtures, fresh interior paint, and new window coverings. 2022 Shared spaces updates: freshly painted laundry room and stairwell, plus refinished hardwood stairs. Additional capital improvements include a radon mitigation system installed in 2023 and the 2011 separation of mechanical systems along with egress window installation, establishing the property's legal duplex status with the City of Fort Collins. Outside, you'll find off-alley parking for up to four vehicles, a charming backyard complete with a white picket fence, and a full two-car garage. The property also earned an impressive 8/10 score on the City of Fort Collins 2024 Energy Audit. Consistently rented with high-quality tenants, this duplex has a proven rental history. Even better, the upstairs lease expires July 31, 2026, creating an ideal opportunity for an owner-occupant looking to offset their mortgage while building long-term wealth. Whether you're a savvy investor or a future house hacker, this Fort Collins gem checks all the boxes.

326 E Pitkin St, Fort Collins

$570,000

Opportunity abounds in this charming Fort Collins listing. Value always stays with location location location! Situated just two blocks from CSU and a block from the Colorado State University Theatre, the Colorado State University School of Music, the Gregory Allicar Museum of Art, and the CSU Annual Trial Flower Gardens you won't find a better location! Also two blocks from restaurants Nick's Italian, Cafe Vino and Saigon Grill. Quiet and peaceful yet close to all your living needs. Close to Old Town Fort Collins with no HOA this is a high demand location for all buyers! Marble kitchen counters with original wainscoting cabinets. New interior paint. Exterior painted in 2023. Hardwood throughout, central cooling and an unfinished basement. An ample front porch with a spacious fully fenced private back yard! This tall elegant corner lot home has established trees, oak, maple and catalpa as well as beautiful lavender and rose bushes. Detached garage, a carport and a cute playhouse! First American Home warranty comes with the home.

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1056919 MLS ⋅ CLOSED Status

Opportunity abounds in this charming Fort Collins listing. Value always stays with location location location! Situated just two blocks from CSU and a block from the Colorado State University Theatre, the Colorado State University School of Music, the Gregory Allicar Museum of Art, and the CSU Annual Trial Flower Gardens you won't find a better location! Also two blocks from restaurants Nick's Italian, Cafe Vino and Saigon Grill. Quiet and peaceful yet close to all your living needs. Close to Old Town Fort Collins with no HOA this is a high demand location for all buyers! Marble kitchen counters with original wainscoting cabinets. New interior paint. Exterior painted in 2023. Hardwood throughout, central cooling and an unfinished basement. An ample front porch with a spacious fully fenced private back yard! This tall elegant corner lot home has established trees, oak, maple and catalpa as well as beautiful lavender and rose bushes. Detached garage, a carport and a cute playhouse! First American Home warranty comes with the home.

225 Edwards St, Fort Collins

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?